Is Monogamy Unbiblical? What Scripture Says About Marriage
A pastor's marriage to a second wife and his claim that monogamy is unbiblical has made headlines. What does the whole counsel of Scripture teach about marriage?
Vanguard News carries a video report of a pastor marrying a second wife and saying that monogamy is unbiblical. Punch Newspapers and The Nation describe him as a US pastor who defends polygamy as biblical. The story has stirred conversation among many believers, and it deserves a calm, Scripture-based reply rather than mockery or anger.
Start where God started
When a claim is made about what the Bible teaches, the best place to begin is the beginning. In Genesis, God did not make a crowd of wives for Adam. He made one woman, and then Scripture tells us what marriage is meant to be:
Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they shall be one flesh. (Genesis 2:24 KJV)
Notice the words: a man, his wife, one flesh. The pattern is union between two people, joined together in a bond of faithful companionship.
Jesus returns to the creation pattern
When the Pharisees questioned Jesus about marriage, He did not point them to the customs of the day. He took them back to Genesis:
Have ye not read, that he which made them at the beginning made them male and female, And said, For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife: and they twain shall be one flesh? Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder. (Matthew 19:4-6 KJV)
Jesus said "they twain", meaning the two. He treated the original design as the standard for marriage. If anyone wants to know what God intended, the words of Christ are the clearest guide we have.
The Bible records polygamy; it does not recommend it
A sincere person may ask, "But did not many men in the Bible have more than one wife?" Yes, they did, and an honest reading must admit it. But there is a big difference between Scripture describing something and Scripture endorsing it. The Bible also records lying, murder, theft and betrayal among God's people, and no one says God approved them.
When we look closely at these households, the Bible does not hide the pain. Abraham took Hagar, and the home was soon filled with jealousy and sorrow (Genesis 16). Jacob's marriages to Leah and Rachel produced years of rivalry and heartache in the family (Genesis 29-30). David's household later knew grief and bitter division among his children. These accounts are not advertisements for plural marriage. They are honest, sobering records of what followed when people moved away from God's pattern.
Scripture even gives a warning to the kings of Israel: the king "shall not multiply wives to himself, that his heart turn not away" (Deuteronomy 17:17 KJV). God knew where the practice could lead the heart.
The standard for those who lead
The New Testament speaks plainly about the character of church leaders. Paul wrote to Timothy:
A bishop then must be blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant, sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality, apt to teach. (1 Timothy 3:2 KJV)
Whatever one's view of how this verse applies in every case, it is hard to read it as a celebration of leaders with many wives. Those who shepherd God's people are to be an example of faithfulness in the home. Paul also uses marriage as a picture of Christ and the church (Ephesians 5:31-32), one Bridegroom and one devoted Bride, and that picture reflects the same pattern God set from the beginning.
A gentle word for Nigerian believers
In Nigeria, many of us know families touched by polygamy. Some of us grew up in such homes, or love people who did. Some of our parents and grandparents lived in that tradition before they came to know Christ. Let us speak with compassion. The question before us is not whether those families are loved by God. They are. The question is what the Scriptures teach about marriage, and we can answer it with humility, not with scorn for any person.
It is also wise to remember that this pastor, like all of us, will answer to God, not to our comments and opinions. Our task is not to condemn a person but to hold fast to the truth.
Test every teaching
The most important lesson in any headline like this is how we respond to teaching of every kind. The believers in Berea are praised for just this:
These were more noble than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word with all readiness of mind, and searched the scriptures daily, whether those things were so. (Acts 17:11 KJV)
Do not believe something because a preacher is charismatic, popular or confident. Do not reject something merely because it is unfamiliar. Open your Bible, read the passage in its context, and ask what the whole of Scripture says. Paul also warned that a time would come when people would turn away from sound teaching and gather teachers who say what they want to hear (2 Timothy 4:3-4). The answer is not fear but a steady, daily love for God's Word.
How we can respond
First, pray for this pastor, for his family and for the congregation, that they would seek the Lord with honest hearts. Second, pray for everyone who leads others in faith, that they would handle Scripture carefully. Third, strengthen the marriages around you: encourage couples, honour your own vows, and support those who are struggling. Finally, make time in the Word a daily habit, so that you are rooted in truth no matter what the headlines say.
A prayer
Father, thank You for the gift of marriage and for the beautiful pattern You gave us from the beginning. Hold close the families and the church community touched by this story, and lead every pastor and teacher to honour Your Word. Give us, Your people, the noble spirit of the Bereans, that we may search the Scriptures daily and hold fast to what is true. Strengthen the marriages in our homes and fill us with grace toward those who disagree. In Jesus' name we pray, Amen.
Quick quiz · what Scripture says about marriage
How well do you know what Scripture says about marriage?
5 quick questions on what you just read. Free, no account needed.
Play 10 questions on Doctrine & Theology →Build a daily reading habit. Follow a plan through the whole Bible, day by day.
Choose a plan →Gospel Genius Editorial Team
Gospel Genius Contributor
Gospel Genius is a Bible knowledge platform helping Christians grow deeper in Scripture through quizzes, daily devotions, reading plans, and study resources. Our contributors are believers passionate about making God's Word accessible to every person.
Learn more about Gospel Genius →